Shy Guy is the founder of the Toast Force, who has extremely good gun skills and fights against the Toad Mafia and anyone who opposes the Toasters for Toast movement.


Shy Guy is obsessed with Toast a d always yells “YA TOAST!!!!” He made friends with Mario due to the fact that he really likes toast.

Acts of TerrorismEdit

Shy Guy murdered Atticus Finch and blamed Giuseppe, among many, many other crimes. He was later excecuted off-screen.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.